|
|
||||||||
2-Selective Adrenergic Agonists against Ischemia-Induced Retinal Ganglion Cell Death
From the Laboratorio de Oftalmología Experimental, Departamento de Oftalmología, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad de Murcia, Spain.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-selective adrenergic agonists (
2-SAs;
AGN 191103 and AGN 190342) on retinal ganglion cell (RGC) survival
after transient retinal ischemia.
METHODS. RGCs were labeled with a Fluorogold (FG) tracer applied to both
superior colliculi. Seven days later, the left ophthalmic vessels were
ligated for 60 or 90 minutes. In one group, a single dose of saline or
one
2-SA was administered intraperitoneally (IP) or
topically 1 hour before ischemia. In another group, a single dose of
AGN 190342 was administered IP, 1, 2, 4, 24, or 72 hours after
ischemia. Rats were processed 7, 14, or 21 days later. Densities of
surviving RGCs were estimated by counting FG-labeled cells in 12
standard retinal areas.
RESULTS. Seven days after 60 or 90 minutes of retinal ischemia, death
had occurred in 36% or 47%, respectively, of the RGC population, and
by 21 days the loss of RGCs amounted to 42% or 62%, respectively.
Systemic pretreatment with an
2-SA resulted in enhanced
survival of ischemic-injured RGCs. Topical pretreatment with an
2-SA prevented up to 100% of the ischemia-induced RGC
loss. Pretreatment with an
2-SA abolished the secondary
slow RGC loss that occurred between days 7 and 21 after ischemia. When
administered shortly after ischemia (up to 2 hours) AGN 190342 rescued
substantial proportions of RGCs destined to die and diminished slow RGC
death.
CONCLUSIONS. Pretreatment and early posttreatment with an
2-SA
induces marked long-lasting neuroprotective in vivo protection against
ischemia-induced cell death in RGCs.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Recently, we have investigated the pattern of RGC loss that follows transient ischemia of the retina induced by elevation of intraocular pressure18 or by selective ligature of the ophthalmic vessels (SLOV).19 In both situations, ischemia-induced RGC death is a progressive event that takes place in at least two phases: an early rapid and a later more protracted period of cell loss. The amount and duration of these periods of cell loss are determined by the duration of the period of ischemia.18 19
The
2-adrenergic receptors are G
proteincoupled receptors localized in the retina within the RGC
layer, inner nuclear layer, and inner segments of the
photoreceptors.20
21
22
Recent evidence indicates that
retinal
2-adrenergic receptors mediate
neuroprotective responses in the retina.
2-Selective adrenergic agonists
(
2-SAs) mediate the expression of bFGF mRNA in
the inner segments of photoreceptors, and this, in turn, may be
responsible for neuroprotection against light-induced photoreceptor
damage.22
In addition,
2-SAs are
neuroprotective for adult rat RGCs against partial crush injury of the
optic nerve (ON).23
Furthermore, preliminary reports
suggest that
2-SAs are neuroprotective against
pressure-induced retinal ischemia24
and chronic elevation
of intraocular pressure.25
We report the effects of two potent
2-SAs (AGN
191103 and AGN 190342) on RGC death induced by SLOV. We present
evidence indicating that
2-SAs, when
administered systemically or topically before retinal ischemia,
resulted in the rescue of up to 100% of the RGC population.
Furthermore, the rescuing effects persisted during the 21-day period of
study, and this resulted in inhibition of the protracted slow phase of
RGC death that follows retinal ischemia. Early posttreatment with an
2-SA also diminished the early rapid and
secondary slow loss of RGCs. Overall, these in vivo studies indicate
that
2-adrenergic receptors mediate a potent
neuroprotective effect in the retina and prevent the devastating
consequences of ischemia on the RGC population.
Parts of this work have been presented in preliminary report and abstract form.26 27
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-AdrenergicSelective Agonists
The
2-SAs
imidazolidin-zylidene-(5-methyl-quinoxalin-6-yl)-amine (AGN
191103) and 5-bromo-6-[2-imidazolin-zyl-amino] quinoxaline (AGN
190342) also known as brimonidine tartrate (BMD) or UK-1434 were
obtained from Allergan, Inc. (Irvine, CA). Yohimbine, a selective
2 adrenoceptor antagonist, was purchased from
Sigma Chemical Co. (Madrid, Spain). Both
2-SAs
were dissolved in saline and either administered intraperitoneally (IP)
or instilled topically on the eye. Yohimbine was dissolved in
phosphate-buffered saline and administered IP.
Surgical Manipulations
Retrograde Labeling of Retinal Ganglion Cells.
RGCs were labeled retrogradely with a Fluorogold (FG) tracer
(Fluorogold; Fluorochrome, Inc., Engelwood, CO) applied to both
superior colliculi (SCi), which are the main RGC targets in the
brain,28
according to described
methods.11
18
19
Rats were anesthetized with an IP
injection of a mixture of ketamine (75 mg/kg; Ketolar; Parke-Davis, SL,
Barcelona, Spain) and xylazine (10 mg/kg; Rompún; Bayer, SA,
Barcelona, Spain) in sterile saline. The midbrain was exposed, the pia
mater overlying the SCi was removed, and a small pledget of gelatin
sponge (Espongostan Film; Ferrosan A/S, Soeborg, Denmark) soaked in a
solution of 3% FG in saline containing 10% dimethyl sulfoxide was
applied over the surface of both SCi to label the RGCs retrogradely.
Previous observations from this laboratory11
18
have
documented that 7 days after FG application in the brain, the densities
of FG-labeled RGCs are similar to those obtained when other
retrogradely transported fluorescent and nonfluorescent tracers are
applied to the main retinorecipient target regions in the
brain.8
9
29
Moreover, FG persists within the somata of
the retrogradely labeled neurons for up to 4 weeks after tracer
application to the target, without apparent leakage or
fading,18
30
thus enabling identification of the RGC
population for up to 4 weeks after application.
Induction of Transient Periods of Retinal Ischemia.
Previous studies from this laboratory have shown that 60 and 90 minutes
of transient ischemia induced by SLOV produce consistent and
predictable patterns of RGC loss that have been recently
characterized.19
Thus, for the present experiments,
periods of 60 or 90 minutes of transient retinal ischemia were induced
in the left eye 7 days after FG application. Transient ischemia in the
left retina was induced by SLOV, according to described
methods.19
31
In brief, the left ON head was exposed in
the orbit,1
the superior aspect of its dural sheath was
opened longitudinally, and a 10-0 nylon suture was introduced between
the dural sheath and the ON and tied around the sheath, to interrupt
blood flow through the ophthalmic vessels, which run in an inferior and
nasal aspect within the sheath.32
33
34
Care was taken not
to damage the ON.
Interruption of retinal blood flow during ischemia was assessed by direct ophthalmoscopy of the eye fundus through the surgical microscope. The animals that did not show a complete interruption of retinal blood flow during the ischemic period were excluded. At the end of the ischemic period, the ligature was released, and retinal reperfusion was assessed through the surgical microscope. The animals that did not show a complete recovery of retinal blood flow within the first few minutes after the ligature was released were also excluded. Eye fundus inspection was facilitated, because most eyes appeared mydriatic after the induction of transient ischemia. When necessary, a drop of 1% tropicamide (Colirio de Tropicamida; Alcon-Cusi Laboratories, Barcelona, Spain) was applied topically to induce mydriasis.
Because xylazine can activate
2-adrenergic
receptors,22
and ketamine may also have a neuroprotective
effect against ischemia,35
for the induction of retinal
ischemia, the animals were anesthetized with an IP injection of 7%
chloral hydrate in saline (0.42 mg/g body weight).
Animals treated with an
2-SA showed prolonged periods of
recovery from anesthesia.
2-adrenergic agonists are used
in clinical anesthesiology before surgery for their hypnotic and
anesthetic properties and after surgery to prolong
sedation.36
Thus, this prolonged recovery from anesthesia
was probably related to the effects of the
2-SA on the
central nervous system (CNS). A dose-dependent hypnotic response in
rats36
37
mediated through the
2-adrenergic receptor subtype in the locus
ceruleus38
has been observed with dexmedetomidine, another
2-SA.
A proportion of the animals treated with an
2-SA also
showed a transient partial opalescence of the lens, which reverted
within the first few minutes after onset of reperfusion. This partial
opalescence of the lens did not preclude assessment of retinal blood
flow through the microscope, and at present we have no clear
explanation for it.
Intraorbital Sectioning of the ON.
In one group of animals, 7 days after FG application the left ON was
sectioned at its exit from the eye, according to previously described
methods.1
8
9
29
In brief, the animals were anesthetized
as for the other surgical manipulations, the ON head was accessed in
the orbit, its dural sheath opened longitudinally, and the ON was
sectioned close to its origin in the eye with scissors. The eye fundus
was examined before and after the procedure, and the animals that
showed any disturbance in retinal blood flow were excluded.
Drug Administration and Groups of Animals
RGC Survival after SLOV.
Effects of Pretreatment with an
2-SA.
In one group, animals subjected to 60- or 90-minute periods of
transient retinal ischemia were pretreated 1 hour before with an
2-SA. These animals were divided into two subgroups,
depending on the route of administration of the
2-SA.
One received a single IP injection of AGN 191103 (0.1 or 0.01 mg/kg
body weight) or BMD (0.1 or 1 mg/kg body weight), and the other
received two 5-µl drops of AGN 191103 (0.1% or 0.05% in saline) or
BMD (0.5% in saline) topically in the left eye. These doses were
selected based on preliminary experiments (data not shown) in which we
examined after 7 days the effects of different doses of BMD (0.0001%,
0.001%, 0.01%, and 0.1% in saline) administered topically 1 hour
before ischemia. As a control, similar groups of animals were treated
with saline administered IP or instilled topically. These animals were
processed 7, 14, or 21 days after ischemia.
To investigate whether the effects observed with an
2-SA
were mediated through
2-adrenergic receptors, in a group
of animals subjected to 90 minutes of retinal ischemia, we administered
a single IP injection of yohimbine (5 mg/kg body weight), a selective
2 adrenoceptor antagonist, 80 minutes before the
induction of retinal ischemia and 20 minutes before IP administration
of a single dose of BMD (1 mg/kg body weight). The effects of yohimbine
alone were also tested in a similar group of rats in which BMD was not
administered. These groups were analyzed 7 days later.
RGC Survival after SLOV.
Effects of Posttreatment with an
2-SA.
An additional group of animals subjected to 90 minutes of retinal
ischemia were treated with an IP injection of BMD (1 mg/kg body weight)
at various times (1, 2, 4, 24, or 72 hours) after the onset of
reperfusion. These animals were processed 7, 14, or 21 days later.
RGC Survival after ON Sectioning.
Effects of the
2-SA.
The animals with the left ON transected intraorbitally were treated 1
hour before with a single IP injection of saline, BMD (1 mg/kg body
weight), or AGN 191103 (0.1 mg/kg body weight) dissolved in saline.
These animals were processed 7 days later.
Tissue Processing
The animals were anesthetized with an overdose of 7% chloral
hydrate and were perfused transcardially through the ascending aorta,
first with saline and then with 4% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M phosphate
buffer (pH 7.4). Both eyes were removed and the retinas were dissected
as flattened wholemounts by making four radial cuts (the deepest one in
the superior pole), postfixed for an additional hour in the same
fixative, rinsed in 0.1 M phosphate buffer, and mounted vitreal side up
on subbed slides and covered with a mounting medium containing 50%
glycerol in 0.1 M sodium carbonate buffer (pH 9) containing 0.04%
p-phenylenediamine.39
Estimation of RGC Survival.
The retinas were examined and photographed through a fluorescence
microscope (Axiophot; Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) equipped with an
ultraviolet (BP365/12, LP397) filter that allows the observation of the
white-gold fluorescence of the tracer.
Mean densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the left experimental retinas, as well as in the right control nonischemic retinas, were estimated according to a protocol already described.8 9 11 18 19 In brief, labeled RGCs were counted in photographs taken from 12 standard rectangular areas (0.36 x 0.24 mm) of each retina situated, three in every retinal quadrant at 0.875, 1.925, and 2.975 mm from the optic disc. The number of labeled cells in the photographs was divided by the area of the region to obtain mean densities of labeled cells per square millimeter, and the densities obtained in the 12 areas were pooled to calculate a mean RGC density per retina. Cell counts were performed by the same investigator in a masked fashion. The identity of the retinas that led to the micrographs was unknown until cell counts from different groups were completed.
Results are reported as mean RGC densities per retina and mean RGC densities (±SEM) per group of animals. Statistical analysis of the differences between groups of retinas or groups of animals was performed by nonparametric ANOVA (Statistix ver. 1.0 for Windows 95; Analytical Software, Tallahassee, FL). The Kruskal-Wallis test was used to compare more than two groups and the Mann-Whitney test was used when comparing two groups only. Differences were considered significant at P < 0.05.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-SAs on RGC survival after 60 or 90 minutes
of retinal ischemia induced by SLOV and different reperfusion
intervals. The main findings of this study can be summarized as
follows: Seven days after transient ischemia of 60 or 90 minutes
duration, there was an early loss of approximately 36% or 47%,
respectively, of the RGC population, followed by a slower loss of 6%
or 15%, respectively, of the RGC population, between days 7 and 21
after ischemia. Systemic or topical pretreatment with a single dose of
an
2-SA protected RGCs from ischemia-induced
cell death. The neuroprotection may affect up to 100% of the RGC
population at 7 days, when
2-SAs are
administered topically. Furthermore, pretreatment with an
2-SAs abolished the slow loss of RGCs that
takes place between 7 and 21 days after insult. Systemic treatment with
a single IP dose of BMD 1 or 2 hours after the onset of reperfusion
reduced the initial as well as the slow loss of RGCs that followed
ischemia. Posttreatment with BMD at 4, 24, or 72 hours after the onset
of reperfusion had no effect on RGC survival after transient ischemia.
FG-Labeled RGCs in Control and Experimental Retinas
In the nonischemic (right) retinas of the experimental animals,
the only retinal cells that appeared labeled with FG were RGCs. These
had the typical punctate and diffuse gold fluorescence delineating
their somas and occasionally the initial segments of their primary
dendrites (Fig. 1)
. Mean densities of FG-labeled RGCs were rather consistent for all the
control groups analyzed. For example, the mean FG-labeled RGC densities
found in the right control retinas of the groups treated with vehicle
or AGN 191103 and analyzed 7, 1, or 21 days later, ;T1-T4>showed
comparable results (Tables 1
2
3
and 4
; Fig. 2A
). However, there were slight variations in mean densities of FG-labeled
RGCs in some of the control right retinas of the groups treated with
BMD (Table 5
; Fig. 4A
). These variations can be attributed to slight differences in
the efficiency of tracer application or in the batches of the tracer
used and have also been observed in previous studies in this
laboratory.11
18
Nevertheless, the overall densities were
comparable to those found in previous studies in which FG was applied
to the superficial layers of the SCi and RGCs were estimated for
similar regions of the retina.11
18
The mean density of
labeled RGCs in the right (nonischemic) retinas of each subgroup of
rats was considered 100% survival for their contralateral,
experimental left retinas.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pretreatment with an
2-SAs
Systemic Administration.
Effects of 60 Minutes of Ischemia.
We initially investigated the effects of systemic pretreatment with an
2-SAs on RGC death induced by SLOV for 60
minutes. By day 7, mean densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the left
retinas had diminished to 64% of those found in the right retinas in
the vehicle-treated group (Table 1)
. RGC densities in the left retinas
of rats pretreated with a single IP dose of an
2-SA 1 hour before ischemia were significantly
greater than those found in the left retinas of the vehicle-treated
animals and corresponded to 97% and 93% of the densities found in
their right retinas, in the groups treated with 0.01 and 0.1 mg/kg AGN
191103, respectively, and to 90% and 93%, in the animals treated with
0.1 and 1 mg/kg BMD, respectively. Thus, at the doses administered in
these experiments, the two
2-SAs greatly
improved RGC survival and rescued between 26% and 33% of the RGC
population by 7 days after ischemia (Table 1)
.
To determine whether the rescue effect observed with the
2-SAs was a transitory phenomenon, two
additional groups of animals pretreated with an IP injection of vehicle
or AGN 191103 (0.01 and 0.1 mg/kg) and subjected to 60 minutes of
ischemia were analyzed 14 and 21 days after injury. The densities of
FG-labeled RGCs in the groups treated with AGN 191103 were still
greater than those obtained in the vehicle-treated groups 14 and 21
days after ischemia. Moreover, RGC densities in the left retinas of the
groups treated with AGN 191103 did not decrease between 7 and 21 days
after ischemia (Table 1)
, showing that in this group there was no
further RGC loss and that the neuroprotective effect induced by the
2-SAs was not transitory but persisted for the
21-day period of study.
Effects of 90 Minutes of Ischemia.
We then investigated the effects of systemic pretreatment with an
2-SA after 90 minutes of transient ischemia,
which is a more severe insult to the retina. In the vehicle-treated
group, RGC densities in the left retinas decreased to approximately
53% by day 7 after ischemia (Fig. 2)
. At this time point, however, RGC
densities in the left eyes of the animals pretreated with an
2-SA were significantly greater than those
obtained in the vehicle-treated animals (Fig. 1)
. Expressed as
proportions of their fellow right eyes, these densities corresponded to
81% and 88% in the animals treated with 0.01 and 0.1 mg/kg of AGN
191103, respectively, and to 91% in the animals treated with BMD (Fig. 2) . Thus, at the doses used in these experiments, the two
2-SAs rescued between 28% and 38% of the RGC
population by 7 days after ischemia (Fig. 2)
.
To determine whether the rescuing effects observed with the
2-SAs were short lived, additional groups of
animals pre-treated with vehicle or with AGN 191103 were analyzed 14
and 21 days after ischemia. The densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the
left retinas of the vehicle-treated group decreased significantly from
53% to 38% between 7 and 21 days after ischemia (Figs. 1
2)
. RGC
densities in the left retinas of the AGN 191103-treated group were
significantly greater than those obtained in the left retinas of the
vehicle-treated group at 14 and 21 days after ischemia. Also, these
densities did not decrease significantly between days 7 and 21 after
ischemia, showing that the rescuing effects were sustained and that the
treatment completely prevented RGC death between these two periods
after ischemia (Figs. 1
2)
. Thus, AGN 191103 not only protected
against the early loss that is apparent by 7 days after ischemia, but
also prevented the slow loss of RGCs observed between days 7 and 21
(Fig. 2)
.
Topical Administration.
Effects of 60 Minutes of Ischemia.
In animals subjected to 60 minutes of ischemia and pretreated topically
with vehicle 1 hour before, the densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the
left retinas had decreased by 7 days to approximately 67% of the
densities found in their right contralateral intact retinas (Table 2)
.
Seven days after ischemia, when the animals were pretreated topically 1
hour before ischemia with two 5-µl drops of saline containing BMD
(0.1% or 0.5%), the mean densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the left
retinas were not different from the densities obtained in the right
control retinas. These results show that BMD had protected the whole
RGC population from ischemia-induced death (Table 2)
.
Effects of 90 Minutes of Ischemia.
The mean RGC densities obtained seven days after injury in the left
retinas of the animals subjected to 90 minutes of ischemia and
pretreated topically with vehicle represented approximately 54% of the
densities found in their right contralateral intact retinas (Table 5)
.
In contrast, the groups of animals treated 1 hour before ischemia with
two 5-µl drops of saline containing BMD (0.1% or 0.5%) or AGN
191103 (0.05%) showed mean densities of FG-labeled RGCs at 7 days that
were similar to those found in the control right eyes (Fig. 3)
. This shows that topical instillation resulted again in maximal
neuroprotection (Table 5) . It is possible that topical instillation of
the drug resulted in higher retinal concentrations,43
and
this would explain the higher results obtained with
2-SAs administered through this route.
|
Effect of
2-Adrenoceptor Inhibitors.
To investigate whether
2-SAs
neuroprotective effects are specifically mediated through
2-adrenoreceptors, we assessed RGC survival
under a combined treatment of yohimbine and BMD. Yohimbine, a selective
inhibitor of
2-adrenoceptors, was administered
shortly before BMD. Seven days after 90 minutes of ischemia, the
densities of labeled RGCs in the left retinas of animals pretreated
with yohimbine and BMD were similar to those found in animals
pretreated with yohimbine alone (Table 3)
. Furthermore, these densities
were similar to the densities found in the left retinas of the animals
that received an IP injection of vehicle (Table 3)
. Thus, yohimbine
blocked the neuroprotective effects of the
2-SA on RGC survival 7 days after 90 minutes
of retinal ischemia, and treatment with yohimbine alone had no effect
on RGC survival. Overall, these results indicate that the
neuroprotective effect of BMD after ischemia was specifically mediated
through
2-adrenoreceptors.
Effect of
2-SAs on RGC Survival after ON Section.
To determine whether
2-SAs were also
effective in preventing axotomy-induced RGC death, additional groups of
rats were pretreated with a single IP injection of saline, AGN 191103
(0.1 mg/kg), or BMD (1 mg/kg) 1 hour before sectioning of the
intraorbital left ON. These animals were analyzed 7 days later.
Concordant with previous studies,10
11
our results show
that 7 days after intraorbital ON transection, approximately 45% of
the RGCs were lost in the group of animals treated with saline.
Comparable results were observed in the groups pretreated with AGN
191103 or BMD (Table 4)
, documenting that these two
2-SAs did not protect RGCs against the effects
of ON section.
Posttreatment with an
2-SA
To investigate whether the administration of an
2-SA after 90 minutes of ischemia had
neuroprotective effects on RGCs, in an additional groups of animals a
single IP dose of BMD (1 mg/kg body weight) was administered 1, 2, 4,
24, or 72 hours after the onset of reperfusion, and the animals were
analyzed 7, 14, or 21 days later. These results were compared with
those obtained in corresponding groups of animals pretreated IP with
saline.
In the group of animals treated 1 hour after ischemia and analyzed 7,
14, or 21 days later, the densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the left
retinas were significantly greater than those obtained in the left
retinas of the vehicle-treated control animals (Fig. 4) . These results show that BMD administered 1 hour after the onset of
reperfusion increased RGC survival after ischemia. Furthermore, because
the densities of FG-labeled RGCs in the left retinas of the animals
treated with BMD did not decrease significantly between 14 and 21 days
after ischemia and the densities of RGCs in the left retinas of the
vehicle-treated rats decreased significantly between these periods, it
is possible that BMD not only rescued a proportion of RGCs from early
death but also halted the slow secondary loss of RGCs observed between
14 and 21 days (Fig. 4)
. The group of animals treated with BMD 2 hours
after ischemia also showed significantly greater densities of
FG-labeled RGCs in the left retinas than the vehicle-treated group, at
both 7 and 21 days after ischemia (Fig. 4)
. However, the densities of
FG-labeled RGCs in the left retinas of the animals posttreated with BMD
4, 24, or 72 hours after ischemia and analyzed 7 or 21 days later were
similar to those found in the vehicle-treated group (Fig. 4A)
. Taken
together, these results indicate that there is a time window of
approximately 2 hours after onset of reperfusion for effective
posttreatment with an
2-SA after retinal
ischemia.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-SAs on ischemia-induced RGC death. We show
that SLOV for 60 or 90 minutes induced the loss at 7 days of
approximately 36% or 47%, respectively, of the RGC population, and
between 7 and 21 days there was an additional loss of 6% or 15%,
respectively. The major finding we report is that pretreatment with an
2-SA can protect the entire RGC population
against ischemia-induced cell death, and this effect persisted for the
21-day period of study. Furthermore, when administered up to 2 hours
after the onset of reperfusion,
2-SAs
increased RGC survival and diminished delayed RGC death.
Early Neuroprotective Effects of Pretreatment with an
2-SA
Seven days after 60 or 90 minutes of ischemia, the percentages of
surviving RGCs diminished to 64% or 53%, respectively, of their
control values. This is in agreement with studies from
this18
19
and other44
45
46
47
48
laboratories
showing an abrupt RGC loss after transient retinal ischemia. A single
IP injection of AGN 191103 or BMD, 1 hour before 60 or 90 minutes of
ischemia resulted 7 days later in the rescue of 26% or 38%,
respectively, of the RGC population. Moreover, topical instillation of
AGN 191103 or BMD, 1 hour before 60 or 90 minutes of ischemia, resulted
7 days later in densities of surviving RGCs similar to those found in
nonischemic fellow retinas (Tables 2
5)
, showing that the
2-SA protected the entire RGC population from
ischemia-induced RGC death. Previous studies have used antiapoptotic
drugs,17
49
N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)
antagonists,50
51
52
nitric oxide synthase
inhibitors,53
neurotrophic factors,17
54
55
56
or gangliosides57
to protect RGCs after ischemia. These
studies show increased RGC survival after ischemia, but none has
reported protection of the entire RGC population. Because the
neuroprotective effects of
2-SAs were
abolished when yohimbine was administered (Table 3)
, it is likely that
the neuroprotective effects of
2-SAs are
mediated through activation of
2-adrenoceptors.
How
2-SAs may prevent the early loss of RGCs
after retinal ischemia is not clear.58
It is known that
2-SAs upregulate retinal levels of endogenous
bFGF and diminish intraocular levels of glutamate and aspartate after
retinal ischemia. Systemic administration of an
2-SA upregulates the expression of bFGF mRNA
in the retina,22
and exogenous administration of bFGF
increases RGC survival after transient pressure-induced retinal
ischemia.54
55
Ischemia-induced neuronal death is
associated with excessive release of excitatory amino acids and
stimulation of the NMDA subtype of ionotropic glutamate
receptors.59
60
The administration of dextromethorphan, a
glutamate receptor antagonist50
and selective NMDA
antagonists48
diminish ischemia-induced RGC loss. Systemic
administration of an
2-SA diminishes
intraocular levels of glutamate and aspartate after pressure-induced
retinal ischemia,61
and increases RGC survival after
partial crush injury to the ON, a lesion that also produces excessive
release of glutamate into the vitreous and mimics
excitotoxicity.23
Sustained Neuroprotective Effects of Pretreatment with an
2-SA
After the early loss of RGCs that occurred in the first 7 days
after ischemia, RGC death progressed within the next 2 weeks. This is
in agreement with a recent study indicating that transient ischemia
induces a rapid loss of RGCs followed by a slower rate of cell death
that progresses during the following weeks.19
The
progressive loss of RGCs observed in the present study was more evident
in the group of animals analyzed after 90 minutes of ischemia. Between
7 and 21 days there was a significant loss of 15% of the RGC
population in the vehicle-treated group. To determine whether the in
vivo protective effects of
2-SAs were
transitory, we examined RGC survival 14 and 21 days after ischemia and
systemic or topical administration of AGN 191103 (Fig. 2
; Table 5
).
Twenty-one days after 90 minutes of transient ischemia, RGC densities
in the group pretreated systemically with AGN 191103 resulted in
densities of FG-labeled RGCs that were comparable to those obtained at
7 days, suggesting that the rescuing effects persisted for the 21-day
period of study (Fig. 2)
. Similarly, topical pretreatment with AGN
190342 resulted by 7 and 14 days in densities of surviving RGCs that
were similar to those in their control contralateral retinas (Table 5)
.
Moreover, in this group of animals, at 21 days the densities of
surviving RGCs did not differ from those obtained at 14 days.
Previous studies on ischemia-induced RGC death have shown increased RGC
survival after ischemia with the administration of exogenous substances
(described earlier), but in most of these studies RGC survival was
investigated only during the first 7 to 14 days after ischemia. Our
results indicate that both the early abrupt and the secondary
protracted phase of cell loss that follows retinal
ischemia19
may be halted with a single dose of an
2-SA administered before ischemia.
Ongoing studies from this laboratory indicate that SLOV also induces
death of other non-RGC neurons,62
and systemic
administration of an
2-SA preserves inner and
outer nuclear retinal cells, as well as the cytoarchitecture of retinal
layers.62
Thus, it is conceivable that the sustained
effects observed in this study are related not only to the initial
rescue of RGCs but also to the preservation of other non-RGC retinal
neurons. Other studies have indicated that ameliorating the early RGC
loss does not ensure prevention of delayed RGC loss.48
Posttreatment Neuroprotective Effects
We further investigated whether
2-SAs
would be neuroprotective when administered after retinal ischemia. When
administered 1 hour after the onset of reperfusion, BMD was also
effective in preventing the death of approximately 19%, 12%, and 22%
of the RGC population by 7, 14, or 21 days, respectively (Fig. 4) .
Moreover, the densities of FG-labeled RGCs did not decrease further
between 14 and 21 days in the BMD-treated groups, but there were
significant reductions in the vehicle-treated groups. Taken together,
these results show that, when administered 1 hour after ischemia, BMD
partially prevented RGC death and diminished the slow loss of RGCs
observed between 7 and 21 days. In the group of animals treated with
BMD 2 hours after ischemia there were also significant neuroprotective
effects. However, the neuroprotective effect was lost when BMD was
injected 4, 24, or 72 hours after onset of reperfusion, presumably
because it were administered at a time when a large proportion of RGCs
were already committed to die.48
RGC death after transient ischemia of the retina may result in both
acute excitotoxic necrotic cell death and delayed apoptotic cell
death.44
45
46
47
48
Because posttreatment with an
2-SA resulted in increased RGC survival after
ischemia and diminished the secondary slow loss of RGCs, it is possible
that
2-SAs have antiapoptotic effects. Recent
studies, in neuronally differentiated PC12 cells deprived of serum and
nerve growth factor (NGF) and in cerebellar granule neurons placed in
low-K+ medium, indicate that
2-SAs may halt apoptotic degradation by
maintaining the mitochondrial permeability and avoiding release of
degradation-signaling factors, suggesting that
2-SAs act early on the cascade of events
leading to apoptosis.63
The absence of neuroprotection of
2-SAs against axotomy-induced RGC death
observed in this study (Table 4)
may be interpreted as an indication
that the pathogenic pathways activated by transient ischemia or axotomy
differ,17
although leading to a common cell death
mechanism, apoptosis. An inhibitor of a late event in apoptosis, the
irreversible wide-range CPP32-like caspase inhibitor Z-DEVD-cmk, was
found to be neuroprotective against both axotomy- and ischemia-induced
RGC death.17
An effect on the early events that lead to
ischemia-induced apoptosis could explain why
2-SAs were effective against ischemia- but not
axotomy-induced RGC death.
Finally, it is possible that the neuroprotective effects of
2-SAs are due to specific upregulation of
survival pathways in the retina through activation of Müller
cells.64
Systemic administration of an
2-SA induces activation in Müller cells
of extracellular signal-regulated kinases (ERKs),64
which
are classic members of the mammalian mitogen-activated protein kinases
(MAPKs). The ERK signaling pathway appears to mediate survival
effects.65
For example, brain-derived neurotrophic factor
(BDNF)mediated neuroprotection in ischemichypoxic brain injury in
vivo is known to be mediated through activation of ERKs.66
In addition to ERKs, two other types of MAPK, known as stress-activated
protein kinases, are thought to be involved in the signaling pathways
to apoptosis induced by various stress and injury stimulus, including
glutamate excitotoxicity17
67
and cerebral
ischemia.68
The observation that
2-SAs selectively activate MAPKs in
Müller cells may be taken as an indication that these cells,
which maintain integrity and normal function of the retina, may play an
important role in protecting retinal neurons.64
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Submitted for publication January 3, 2001; revised April 2, 2001; accepted May 15, 2001.
Commercial relationships policy: F.
The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C.
1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Corresponding author: Manuel Vidal-Sanz, Departamento de Oftalmología, Universidad de Murcia, E-30.100 Espinardo, Murcia, Spain. ofmmv01{at}fcu.um.es
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-Adrenergic agonists induced basic fibroblast growth factor expression in photoreceptors in vivo and ameliorate light damage J Neurosci 16,5986-5992
2-Adrenoreceptor agonists are neuroprotective in a rat model of optic nerve degeneration Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 40,65-73
2-adrenergic receptor Anesthesiology 69,818-823[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
2-adrenoreceptor inhibits vitreal glutamate and aspartate accumulation and preserve retinal function after transient ischemia J Pharmacol Exp Ther 296,216-223